source: src/InitTweak/FixInitNew.cpp@ 0ab3b73

#include "FixInit.h"

#include <stddef.h>                    // for NULL
#include <algorithm>                   // for set_difference, copy_if
#include <cassert>                     // for assert, strict_dynamic_cast
#include <iostream>                    // for operator<<, ostream, basic_ost...
#include <iterator>                    // for insert_iterator, back_inserter
#include <list>                        // for _List_iterator, list, list<>::...
#include <map>                         // for _Rb_tree_iterator, _Rb_tree_co...
#include <memory>                      // for allocator_traits<>::value_type
#include <set>                         // for set, set<>::value_type
#include <unordered_map>               // for unordered_map, unordered_map<>...
#include <unordered_set>               // for unordered_set
#include <utility>                     // for pair

#include "CodeGen/GenType.h"           // for genPrettyType
#include "CodeGen/OperatorTable.h"
#include "Common/PassVisitor.h"        // for PassVisitor, WithStmtsToAdd
#include "Common/SemanticError.h"      // for SemanticError
#include "Common/UniqueName.h"         // for UniqueName
#include "Common/utility.h"            // for CodeLocation, ValueGuard, toSt...
#include "FixGlobalInit.h"             // for fixGlobalInit
#include "GenInit.h"                   // for genCtorDtor
#include "GenPoly/GenPoly.h"           // for getFunctionType
#include "InitTweak.h"                 // for getFunctionName, getCallArg
#include "ResolvExpr/Resolver.h"       // for findVoidExpression
#include "ResolvExpr/typeops.h"        // for typesCompatible
#include "SymTab/Autogen.h"            // for genImplicitCall
#include "SymTab/Indexer.h"            // for Indexer
#include "SymTab/Mangler.h"            // for Mangler
#include "SynTree/LinkageSpec.h"       // for C, Spec, Cforall, isBuiltin
#include "SynTree/Attribute.h"         // for Attribute
#include "SynTree/Constant.h"          // for Constant
#include "SynTree/Declaration.h"       // for ObjectDecl, FunctionDecl, Decl...
#include "SynTree/Expression.h"        // for UniqueExpr, VariableExpr, Unty...
#include "SynTree/Initializer.h"       // for ConstructorInit, SingleInit
#include "SynTree/Label.h"             // for Label, operator<
#include "SynTree/Mutator.h"           // for mutateAll, Mutator, maybeMutate
#include "SynTree/Statement.h"         // for ExprStmt, CompoundStmt, Branch...
#include "SynTree/Type.h"              // for Type, Type::StorageClasses
#include "SynTree/TypeSubstitution.h"  // for TypeSubstitution, operator<<
#include "SynTree/DeclReplacer.h"      // for DeclReplacer
#include "SynTree/Visitor.h"           // for acceptAll, maybeAccept
#include "Validate/FindSpecialDecls.h" // for dtorStmt, dtorStructDestroy

#include "AST/Expr.hpp"
#include "AST/Node.hpp"
#include "AST/Pass.hpp"
#include "AST/Print.hpp"
#include "AST/SymbolTable.hpp"
#include "AST/Type.hpp"
#include "AST/DeclReplacer.hpp"

extern bool ctordtorp; // print all debug
extern bool ctorp; // print ctor debug
extern bool cpctorp; // print copy ctor debug
extern bool dtorp; // print dtor debug
#define PRINT( text ) if ( ctordtorp ) { text }
#define CP_CTOR_PRINT( text ) if ( ctordtorp || cpctorp ) { text }
#define DTOR_PRINT( text ) if ( ctordtorp || dtorp ) { text }

namespace InitTweak {
        namespace {
                struct SelfAssignChecker {
                        void previsit( const ast::ApplicationExpr * appExpr );
                };

                struct StmtExprResult {
                        static void link( std::list<ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit );

                        const ast::StmtExpr * previsit( const ast::StmtExpr * stmtExpr );
                };

                struct InsertImplicitCalls : public ast::WithConstTypeSubstitution, public ast::WithShortCircuiting {
                        /// wrap function application expressions as ImplicitCopyCtorExpr nodes so that it is easy to identify which
                        /// function calls need their parameters to be copy constructed
                        static void insert( std::list<ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit );

                        const ast::Expr * postvisit( const ast::ApplicationExpr * appExpr );

                        // only handles each UniqueExpr once
                        // if order of visit does not change, this should be safe
                        void previsit (const ast::UniqueExpr *);

                        std::unordered_set<decltype(ast::UniqueExpr::id)> visitedIds;
                };

                struct ResolveCopyCtors final : public ast::WithGuards, public ast::WithStmtsToAdd<>, public ast::WithSymbolTable, public ast::WithShortCircuiting, public ast::WithVisitorRef<ResolveCopyCtors> {
                        /// generate temporary ObjectDecls for each argument and return value of each ImplicitCopyCtorExpr,
                        /// generate/resolve copy construction expressions for each, and generate/resolve destructors for both
                        /// arguments and return value temporaries
                        static void resolveImplicitCalls( std::list<ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit );

                        const ast::Expr * postvisit( const ast::ImplicitCopyCtorExpr * impCpCtorExpr );
                        const ast::StmtExpr * previsit( const ast::StmtExpr * stmtExpr );
                        const ast::UniqueExpr * previsit( const ast::UniqueExpr * unqExpr );

                        /// handles distant mutations of environment manually. 
                        /// WithConstTypeSubstitution cannot remember where the environment is from

                        /// MUST be called at start of overload previsit
                        void previsit( const ast::Expr * expr);
                        /// MUST be called at return of overload postvisit
                        const ast::Expr * postvisit(const ast::Expr * expr);

                        /// create and resolve ctor/dtor expression: fname(var, [cpArg])
                        const ast::Expr * makeCtorDtor( const std::string & fname, const ast::ObjectDecl * var, const ast::Expr * cpArg = nullptr );
                        /// true if type does not need to be copy constructed to ensure correctness
                        bool skipCopyConstruct( const ast::Type * type );
                        ast::ptr< ast::Expr > copyConstructArg( const ast::Expr * arg, const ast::ImplicitCopyCtorExpr * impCpCtorExpr, const ast::Type * formal );
                        ast::Expr * destructRet( const ast::ObjectDecl * ret, const ast::Expr * arg );
                private:
                        /// hack to implement WithTypeSubstitution while conforming to mutation safety.
                        ast::TypeSubstitution * env;
                        bool                    envModified;
                };

                /// collects constructed object decls - used as a base class
                struct ObjDeclCollector : public ast::WithGuards, public ast::WithShortCircuiting {
                        // use ordered data structure to maintain ordering for set_difference and for consistent error messages
                        typedef std::list< const ast::ObjectDecl * > ObjectSet;
                        void previsit( const ast::CompoundStmt *compoundStmt );
                        void previsit( const ast::DeclStmt *stmt );

                        // don't go into other functions
                        void previsit( const ast::FunctionDecl * ) { visit_children = false; }

                  protected:
                        ObjectSet curVars;
                };

                // debug
                template<typename ObjectSet>
                struct PrintSet {
                        PrintSet( const ObjectSet & objs ) : objs( objs ) {}
                        const ObjectSet & objs;
                };
                template<typename ObjectSet>
                PrintSet<ObjectSet> printSet( const ObjectSet & objs ) { return PrintSet<ObjectSet>( objs ); }
                template<typename ObjectSet>
                std::ostream & operator<<( std::ostream & out, const PrintSet<ObjectSet> & set) {
                        out << "{ ";
                        for ( auto & obj : set.objs ) {
                                out << obj->name << ", " ;
                        } // for
                        out << " }";
                        return out;
                }

                struct LabelFinder final : public ObjDeclCollector {
                        typedef std::map< std::string, ObjectSet > LabelMap;
                        // map of Label -> live variables at that label
                        LabelMap vars;

                        typedef ObjDeclCollector Parent;
                        using Parent::previsit;
                        void previsit( const ast::Stmt * stmt );

                        void previsit( const ast::CompoundStmt *compoundStmt );
                        void previsit( const ast::DeclStmt *stmt );
                };

                struct InsertDtors final : public ObjDeclCollector, public ast::WithStmtsToAdd<> {
                        /// insert destructor calls at the appropriate places.  must happen before CtorInit nodes are removed
                        /// (currently by FixInit)
                        static void insert( std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit );

                        typedef std::list< ObjectDecl * > OrderedDecls;
                        typedef std::list< OrderedDecls > OrderedDeclsStack;

                        InsertDtors( ast::Pass<LabelFinder> & finder ) : finder( finder ), labelVars( finder.core.vars ) {}

                        typedef ObjDeclCollector Parent;
                        using Parent::previsit;

                        void previsit( const ast::FunctionDecl * funcDecl );

                        void previsit( const ast::BranchStmt * stmt );
                private:
                        void handleGoto( const ast::BranchStmt * stmt );

                        ast::Pass<LabelFinder> & finder;
                        LabelFinder::LabelMap & labelVars;
                        OrderedDeclsStack reverseDeclOrder;
                };

                class FixInit : public ast::WithStmtsToAdd<> {
                  public:
                        /// expand each object declaration to use its constructor after it is declared.
                        static void fixInitializers( std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > &translationUnit );

                        const ast::DeclWithType * postvisit( const ast::ObjectDecl *objDecl );

                        std::list< ast::ptr< ast::Decl > > staticDtorDecls;
                };

                struct GenStructMemberCalls final : public ast::WithGuards, public ast::WithShortCircuiting, public ast::WithSymbolTable, public ast::WithVisitorRef<GenStructMemberCalls> {
                        /// generate default/copy ctor and dtor calls for user-defined struct ctor/dtors
                        /// for any member that is missing a corresponding ctor/dtor call.
                        /// error if a member is used before constructed
                        static void generate( std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit );

                        void previsit( const ast::FunctionDecl * funcDecl );
                        const ast::DeclWithType * postvisit( const ast::FunctionDecl * funcDecl );

                        void previsit( const ast::MemberExpr * memberExpr );
                        void previsit( const ast::ApplicationExpr * appExpr );

                        /// Note: this post mutate used to be in a separate visitor. If this pass breaks, one place to examine is whether it is
                        /// okay for this part of the recursion to occur alongside the rest.
                        const ast::Expr * postvisit( const ast::UntypedExpr * expr );

                        SemanticErrorException errors;
                  private:
                        template< typename... Params >
                        void emit( CodeLocation, const Params &... params );

                        ast::FunctionDecl * function = nullptr;
                        std::set< const ast::DeclWithType * > unhandled;
                        std::map< const ast::DeclWithType *, CodeLocation > usedUninit;
                        const ast::ObjectDecl * thisParam = nullptr;
                        bool isCtor = false; // true if current function is a constructor
                        const ast::StructDecl * structDecl = nullptr;
                };

                struct FixCtorExprs final : public ast::WithDeclsToAdd<>, public ast::WithSymbolTable, public ast::WithShortCircuiting {
                        /// expands ConstructorExpr nodes into comma expressions, using a temporary for the first argument
                        static void fix( std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit );

                        const ast::Expr * postvisit( const ast::ConstructorExpr * ctorExpr );
                };

                struct SplitExpressions : public ast::WithShortCircuiting {
                        /// add CompoundStmts around top-level expressions so that temporaries are destroyed in the correct places.
                        static void split( std::list<ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit );

                        ast::Stmt * postvisit( const ast::ExprStmt * stmt );
                        void previsit( const ast::TupleAssignExpr * expr );
                };
        } // namespace

        void fix( std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit, bool inLibrary ) {
                ast::Pass<SelfAssignChecker> checker;
                accept_all( translationUnit, checker );

                // fixes StmtExpr to properly link to their resulting expression
                StmtExprResult::link( translationUnit );

                // fixes ConstructorInit for global variables. should happen before fixInitializers.
                InitTweak::fixGlobalInit( translationUnit, inLibrary );

                // must happen before ResolveCopyCtors because temporaries have to be inserted into the correct scope
                SplitExpressions::split( translationUnit );

                InsertImplicitCalls::insert( translationUnit );

                // Needs to happen before ResolveCopyCtors, because argument/return temporaries should not be considered in
                // error checking branch statements
                InsertDtors::insert( translationUnit );

                ResolveCopyCtors::resolveImplicitCalls( translationUnit );
                FixInit::fixInitializers( translationUnit );
                GenStructMemberCalls::generate( translationUnit );

                // Needs to happen after GenStructMemberCalls, since otherwise member constructors exprs
                // don't have the correct form, and a member can be constructed more than once.
                FixCtorExprs::fix( translationUnit );
        }

        namespace {
                /// find and return the destructor used in `input`. If `input` is not a simple destructor call, generate a thunk
                /// that wraps the destructor, insert it into `stmtsToAdd` and return the new function declaration
                const ast::DeclWithType * getDtorFunc( const ast::ObjectDecl * objDecl, const ast::Stmt * input, std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Stmt> > & stmtsToAdd ) {
                        const CodeLocation loc = input->location;
                        // unwrap implicit statement wrapper
                        // Statement * dtor = input;
                        assert( input );
                        // std::list< const ast::Expr * > matches;
                        auto matches = collectCtorDtorCalls( input );

                        if ( dynamic_cast< const ast::ExprStmt * >( input ) ) {
                                // only one destructor call in the expression
                                if ( matches.size() == 1 ) {
                                        auto func = getFunction( matches.front() );
                                        assertf( func, "getFunction failed to find function in %s", toString( matches.front() ).c_str() );

                                        // cleanup argument must be a function, not an object (including function pointer)
                                        if ( auto dtorFunc = dynamic_cast< const ast::FunctionDecl * > ( func ) ) {
                                                if ( dtorFunc->type->forall.empty() ) {
                                                        // simple case where the destructor is a monomorphic function call - can simply
                                                        // use that function as the cleanup function.
                                                        return func;
                                                }
                                        }
                                }
                        }

                        // otherwise the cleanup is more complicated - need to build a single argument cleanup function that
                        // wraps the more complicated code.
                        static UniqueName dtorNamer( "__cleanup_dtor" );
                        std::string name = dtorNamer.newName();
                        ast::FunctionDecl * dtorFunc = SymTab::genDefaultFunc( loc, name, objDecl->type->stripReferences(), false );
                        stmtsToAdd.push_back( new ast::DeclStmt(loc, dtorFunc ) );

                        // the original code contains uses of objDecl - replace them with the newly generated 'this' parameter.
                        const ast::ObjectDecl * thisParam = getParamThis( dtorFunc );
                        const ast::Expr * replacement = new ast::VariableExpr( loc, thisParam );

                        auto base = replacement->result->stripReferences();
                        if ( dynamic_cast< const ast::ArrayType * >( base ) || dynamic_cast< const ast::TupleType * > ( base ) ) {
                                // need to cast away reference for array types, since the destructor is generated without the reference type,
                                // and for tuple types since tuple indexing does not work directly on a reference
                                replacement = new ast::CastExpr( replacement, base );
                        }
                        auto dtor = ast::DeclReplacer::replace( input, ast::DeclReplacer::ExprMap{ std::make_pair( objDecl, replacement ) } );
                        auto mutStmts = dtorFunc->stmts.get_and_mutate();
                        mutStmts->push_back(strict_dynamic_cast<const ast::Stmt *>( dtor ));
                        dtorFunc->stmts = mutStmts;

                        return dtorFunc;
                }

                void StmtExprResult::link( std::list<ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit ) {
                        ast::Pass<StmtExprResult> linker;
                        accept_all( translationUnit, linker );
                }

                void SplitExpressions::split( std::list<ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit ) {
                        ast::Pass<SplitExpressions> splitter;
                        accept_all( translationUnit, splitter );
                }

                void InsertImplicitCalls::insert( std::list<ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit ) {
                        ast::Pass<InsertImplicitCalls> inserter;
                        accept_all( translationUnit, inserter );
                }

                void ResolveCopyCtors::resolveImplicitCalls( std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit ) {
                        ast::Pass<ResolveCopyCtors> resolver;
                        accept_all( translationUnit, resolver );
                }

                void FixInit::fixInitializers( std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit ) {
                        ast::Pass<FixInit> fixer;

                        // can't use mutateAll, because need to insert declarations at top-level
                        // can't use DeclMutator, because sometimes need to insert IfStmt, etc.
                        SemanticErrorException errors;
                        for ( auto i = translationUnit.begin(); i != translationUnit.end(); ++i ) {
                                try {
                                        // maybeAccept( *i, fixer ); translationUnit should never contain null
                                        *i = (*i)->accept(fixer);
                                        translationUnit.splice( i, fixer.core.staticDtorDecls );
                                } catch( SemanticErrorException &e ) {
                                        errors.append( e );
                                } // try
                        } // for
                        if ( ! errors.isEmpty() ) {
                                throw errors;
                        } // if
                }

                void InsertDtors::insert( std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit ) {
                        ast::Pass<LabelFinder> finder;
                        ast::Pass<InsertDtors> inserter( finder );
                        accept_all( translationUnit, inserter );
                }

                void GenStructMemberCalls::generate( std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit ) {
                        ast::Pass<GenStructMemberCalls> warner;
                        accept_all( translationUnit, warner );
                }

                void FixCtorExprs::fix( std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Decl> > & translationUnit ) {
                        ast::Pass<FixCtorExprs> fixer;
                        accept_all( translationUnit, fixer );
                }

                const ast::StmtExpr * StmtExprResult::previsit( const ast::StmtExpr * stmtExpr ) {
                        // we might loose the result expression here so add a pointer to trace back
                        assert( stmtExpr->result );
                        const ast::Type * result = stmtExpr->result;
                        if ( ! result->isVoid() ) {
                                auto mutExpr = mutate(stmtExpr);
                                const ast::CompoundStmt * body = mutExpr->stmts;
                                assert( ! body->kids.empty() );
                                mutExpr->resultExpr = body->kids.back().strict_as<ast::ExprStmt>();
                                return mutExpr;
                        }
                        return stmtExpr;
                }

                ast::Stmt * SplitExpressions::postvisit( const ast::ExprStmt * stmt ) {
                        // wrap each top-level ExprStmt in a block so that destructors for argument and return temporaries are destroyed
                        // in the correct places
                        ast::CompoundStmt * ret = new ast::CompoundStmt( stmt->location, { stmt } );
                        return ret;
                }

                void SplitExpressions::previsit( const ast::TupleAssignExpr * ) {
                        // don't do this within TupleAssignExpr, since it is already broken up into multiple expressions
                        visit_children = false;
                }

                // Relatively simple structural comparison for expressions, needed to determine
                // if two expressions are "the same" (used to determine if self assignment occurs)
                struct StructuralChecker {
                        const ast::Expr * stripCasts( const ast::Expr * expr ) {
                                // this might be too permissive. It's possible that only particular casts are relevant.
                                while ( auto cast = dynamic_cast< const ast::CastExpr * >( expr ) ) {
                                        expr = cast->arg;
                                }
                                return expr;
                        }

                        void previsit( const ast::Expr * ) {
                                // anything else does not qualify
                                isSimilar = false;
                        }

                        template<typename T>
                        T * cast( const ast::Expr * node ) {
                                // all expressions need to ignore casts, so this bit has been factored out
                                return dynamic_cast< T * >( stripCasts( node ) );
                        }

                        // ignore casts
                        void previsit( const ast::CastExpr * ) {}

                        void previsit( const ast::MemberExpr * memExpr ) {
                                if ( auto otherMember = cast< const ast::MemberExpr >( other ) ) {
                                        if ( otherMember->member == memExpr->member ) {
                                                other = otherMember->aggregate;
                                                return;
                                        }
                                }
                                isSimilar = false;
                        }

                        void previsit( const ast::VariableExpr * varExpr ) {
                                if ( auto otherVar = cast< const ast::VariableExpr >( other ) ) {
                                        if ( otherVar->var == varExpr->var ) {
                                                return;
                                        }
                                }
                                isSimilar = false;
                        }

                        void previsit( const ast::AddressExpr * ) {
                                if ( auto addrExpr = cast< const ast::AddressExpr >( other ) ) {
                                        other = addrExpr->arg;
                                        return;
                                }
                                isSimilar = false;
                        }

                        const ast::Expr * other = nullptr;
                        bool isSimilar = true;
                };

                bool structurallySimilar( const ast::Expr * e1, const ast::Expr * e2 ) {
                        ast::Pass<StructuralChecker> checker;
                        checker.core.other = e2;
                        e1->accept( checker );
                        return checker.core.isSimilar;
                }

                void SelfAssignChecker::previsit( const ast::ApplicationExpr * appExpr ) {
                        auto function = getFunction( appExpr );
                        if ( function->name == "?=?" ) { // doesn't use isAssignment, because ?+=?, etc. should not count as self-assignment
                                if ( appExpr->args.size() == 2 ) {
                                        // check for structural similarity (same variable use, ignore casts, etc. - but does not look too deeply, anything looking like a function is off limits)
                                        if ( structurallySimilar( appExpr->args.front(), appExpr->args.back() ) ) {
                                                SemanticWarning( appExpr->location, Warning::SelfAssignment, toCString( appExpr->args.front() ) );
                                        }
                                }
                        }
                }

                const ast::Expr * InsertImplicitCalls::postvisit( const ast::ApplicationExpr * appExpr ) {
                        if ( auto function = appExpr->func.as<ast::VariableExpr>() ) {
                                if ( function->var->linkage.is_builtin ) {
                                        // optimization: don't need to copy construct in order to call intrinsic functions
                                        return appExpr;
                                } else if ( auto funcDecl = function->var.as<ast::DeclWithType>() ) {
                                        auto ftype = dynamic_cast< const ast::FunctionType * >( GenPoly::getFunctionType( funcDecl->get_type() ) );
                                        assertf( ftype, "Function call without function type: %s", toString( funcDecl ).c_str() );
                                        if ( CodeGen::isConstructor( funcDecl->name ) && ftype->params.size() == 2 ) {
                                                auto t1 = getPointerBase( ftype->params.front() );
                                                auto t2 = ftype->params.back();
                                                assert( t1 );

                                                if ( ResolvExpr::typesCompatible( t1, t2 ) ) {
                                                        // optimization: don't need to copy construct in order to call a copy constructor
                                                        return appExpr;
                                                } // if
                                        } else if ( CodeGen::isDestructor( funcDecl->name ) ) {
                                                // correctness: never copy construct arguments to a destructor
                                                return appExpr;
                                        } // if
                                } // if
                        } // if
                        CP_CTOR_PRINT( std::cerr << "InsertImplicitCalls: adding a wrapper " << appExpr << std::endl; )

                        // wrap each function call so that it is easy to identify nodes that have to be copy constructed
                        ast::ptr<ast::TypeSubstitution> tmp = appExpr->env;
                        auto mutExpr = mutate(appExpr);
                        mutExpr->env = nullptr;

                        auto expr = new ast::ImplicitCopyCtorExpr( appExpr->location, mutExpr );
                        // Move the type substitution to the new top-level, if it is attached to the appExpr.
                        // Ensure it is not deleted with the ImplicitCopyCtorExpr by removing it before deletion.
                        // The substitution is needed to obtain the type of temporary variables so that copy constructor
                        // calls can be resolved.
                        assert( typeSubs );
                        // assert (mutExpr->env);
                        expr->env = tmp;
                        // mutExpr->env = nullptr;
                        //std::swap( expr->env, appExpr->env );
                        return expr;
                }

                void ResolveCopyCtors::previsit(const ast::Expr * expr) {
                        if (expr->env) {
                                GuardValue(env);
                                GuardValue(envModified);
                                env = expr->env->clone();
                                envModified = false;
                        }
                }

                const ast::Expr * ResolveCopyCtors::postvisit(const ast::Expr * expr) {
                        if (expr->env) {
                                if (envModified) {
                                        auto mutExpr = mutate(expr);
                                        mutExpr->env = env;
                                        return mutExpr;
                                }
                                else {
                                        // env was not mutated, skip and delete the shallow copy
                                        delete env;
                                        return expr;
                                }
                        }
                        else {
                                return expr;
                        }
                }

                bool ResolveCopyCtors::skipCopyConstruct( const ast::Type * type ) { return ! isConstructable( type ); }

                const ast::Expr * ResolveCopyCtors::makeCtorDtor( const std::string & fname, const ast::ObjectDecl * var, const ast::Expr * cpArg ) {
                        assert( var );
                        assert (var->isManaged());
                        assert (!cpArg || cpArg->isManaged());
                        // arrays are not copy constructed, so this should always be an ExprStmt
                        ast::ptr< ast::Stmt > stmt = genCtorDtor(var->location, fname, var, cpArg );
                        assertf( stmt, "ResolveCopyCtors: genCtorDtor returned nullptr: %s / %s / %s", fname.c_str(), toString( var ).c_str(), toString( cpArg ).c_str() );
                        auto exprStmt = stmt.strict_as<ast::ImplicitCtorDtorStmt>()->callStmt.strict_as<ast::ExprStmt>();
                        ast::ptr<ast::Expr> untyped = exprStmt->expr; // take ownership of expr
                        // exprStmt->expr = nullptr; 

                        // resolve copy constructor
                        // should only be one alternative for copy ctor and dtor expressions, since all arguments are fixed
                        // (VariableExpr and already resolved expression)
                        CP_CTOR_PRINT( std::cerr << "ResolvingCtorDtor " << untyped << std::endl; )
                        ast::ptr<ast::Expr> resolved = ResolvExpr::findVoidExpression(untyped, symtab);
                        assert( resolved );
                        if ( resolved->env ) {
                                // Extract useful information and discard new environments. Keeping them causes problems in PolyMutator passes.
                                env->add( *resolved->env );
                                envModified = true;
                                // delete resolved->env;
                                auto mut = mutate(resolved.get());
                                assertf(mut == resolved.get(), "newly resolved expression must be unique");
                                mut->env = nullptr;
                        } // if
                        // delete stmt;
                        if ( auto assign = resolved.as<ast::TupleAssignExpr>() ) {
                                // fix newly generated StmtExpr
                                previsit( assign->stmtExpr );
                        }
                        return resolved.release();
                }

                ast::ptr<ast::Expr> ResolveCopyCtors::copyConstructArg( 
                        const ast::Expr * arg, const ast::ImplicitCopyCtorExpr * impCpCtorExpr, const ast::Type * formal )
                {
                        static UniqueName tempNamer("_tmp_cp");
                        assert( env );
                        const CodeLocation loc = impCpCtorExpr->location;
                        // CP_CTOR_PRINT( std::cerr << "Type Substitution: " << *env << std::endl; )
                        assert( arg->result );
                        ast::ptr<ast::Type> result = arg->result;
                        if ( skipCopyConstruct( result ) ) return arg; // skip certain non-copyable types

                        // type may involve type variables, so apply type substitution to get temporary variable's actual type,
                        // since result type may not be substituted (e.g., if the type does not appear in the parameter list)
                        // Use applyFree so that types bound in function pointers are not substituted, e.g. in forall(dtype T) void (*)(T).
                        
                        // xxx - this originally mutates arg->result in place. is it correct?
                        result = env->applyFree( result.get() ).node;
                        auto mutResult = result.get_and_mutate();
                        mutResult->set_const(false);

                        auto mutArg = mutate(arg);
                        mutArg->result = mutResult;

                        ast::ptr<ast::Expr> guard = mutArg;

                        ast::ptr<ast::ObjectDecl> tmp = new ast::ObjectDecl({}, "__tmp", mutResult, nullptr );

                        // create and resolve copy constructor
                        CP_CTOR_PRINT( std::cerr << "makeCtorDtor for an argument" << std::endl; )
                        auto cpCtor = makeCtorDtor( "?{}", tmp, mutArg );

                        if ( auto appExpr = dynamic_cast< const ast::ApplicationExpr * >( cpCtor ) ) {
                                // if the chosen constructor is intrinsic, the copy is unnecessary, so
                                // don't create the temporary and don't call the copy constructor
                                auto function = appExpr->func.strict_as<ast::VariableExpr>();
                                if ( function->var->linkage == ast::Linkage::Intrinsic ) {
                                        // arguments that need to be boxed need a temporary regardless of whether the copy constructor is intrinsic,
                                        // so that the object isn't changed inside of the polymorphic function
                                        if ( ! GenPoly::needsBoxing( formal, result, impCpCtorExpr->callExpr, env ) ) {
                                                // xxx - should arg->result be mutated? see comment above.
                                                return guard;
                                        }
                                }
                        }

                        // set a unique name for the temporary once it's certain the call is necessary
                        auto mut = tmp.get_and_mutate();
                        assertf (mut == tmp, "newly created ObjectDecl must be unique");
                        mut->name = tempNamer.newName();

                        // replace argument to function call with temporary
                        stmtsToAddBefore.push_back( new ast::DeclStmt(loc, tmp ) );
                        arg = cpCtor;
                        return destructRet( tmp, arg );

                        // impCpCtorExpr->dtors.push_front( makeCtorDtor( "^?{}", tmp ) );
                }

                ast::Expr * ResolveCopyCtors::destructRet( const ast::ObjectDecl * ret, const ast::Expr * arg ) {
                        // TODO: refactor code for generating cleanup attribute, since it's common and reused in ~3-4 places
                        // check for existing cleanup attribute before adding another(?)
                        // need to add __Destructor for _tmp_cp variables as well

                        assertf( ast::dtorStruct && ast::dtorStruct->members.size() == 2, "Destructor generation requires __Destructor definition." );
                        assertf( ast::dtorStructDestroy, "Destructor generation requires __destroy_Destructor." );

                        const CodeLocation loc = ret->location;

                        // generate a __Destructor for ret that calls the destructor
                        auto res = makeCtorDtor( "^?{}", ret );
                        auto dtor = mutate(res);

                        // if the chosen destructor is intrinsic, elide the generated dtor handler
                        if ( arg && isIntrinsicCallExpr( dtor ) ) {
                                return new ast::CommaExpr(loc, arg, new ast::VariableExpr(loc, ret ) );
                                // return;
                        }

                        if ( ! dtor->env ) dtor->env = maybeClone( env );
                        auto dtorFunc = getDtorFunc( ret, new ast::ExprStmt(loc, dtor ), stmtsToAddBefore );

                        auto dtorStructType = new ast::StructInstType(ast::dtorStruct);

                        // what does this do???
                        dtorStructType->params.push_back( new ast::TypeExpr(loc, new ast::VoidType() ) );

                        // cast destructor pointer to void (*)(void *), to silence GCC incompatible pointer warnings
                        auto dtorFtype = new ast::FunctionType();
                        dtorFtype->params.push_back( new ast::PointerType(new ast::VoidType( ) ) );
                        auto dtorType = new ast::PointerType( dtorFtype );

                        static UniqueName namer( "_ret_dtor" );
                        auto retDtor = new ast::ObjectDecl(loc, namer.newName(), dtorStructType, new ast::ListInit(loc, { new ast::SingleInit(loc, ast::ConstantExpr::null(loc) ), new ast::SingleInit(loc, new ast::CastExpr( new ast::VariableExpr(loc, dtorFunc ), dtorType ) ) } ) );
                        retDtor->attributes.push_back( new ast::Attribute( "cleanup", { new ast::VariableExpr(loc, ast::dtorStructDestroy ) } ) );
                        stmtsToAddBefore.push_back( new ast::DeclStmt(loc, retDtor ) );

                        if ( arg ) {
                                auto member = new ast::MemberExpr(loc, ast::dtorStruct->members.front().strict_as<ast::DeclWithType>(), new ast::VariableExpr(loc, retDtor ) );
                                auto object = new ast::CastExpr( new ast::AddressExpr( new ast::VariableExpr(loc, ret ) ), new ast::PointerType(new ast::VoidType() ) );
                                ast::Expr * assign = createBitwiseAssignment( member, object );
                                return new ast::CommaExpr(loc, new ast::CommaExpr(loc, arg, assign ), new ast::VariableExpr(loc, ret ) );
                        }
                        return nullptr;
                        // impCpCtorExpr->get_dtors().push_front( makeCtorDtor( "^?{}", ret ) );
                }

                const ast::Expr * ResolveCopyCtors::postvisit( const ast::ImplicitCopyCtorExpr *impCpCtorExpr ) {
                        CP_CTOR_PRINT( std::cerr << "ResolveCopyCtors: " << impCpCtorExpr << std::endl; )

                        ast::ApplicationExpr * appExpr = mutate(impCpCtorExpr->callExpr.get());
                        const ast::ObjectDecl * returnDecl = nullptr;
                        const CodeLocation loc = appExpr->location;

                        // take each argument and attempt to copy construct it.
                        auto ftype = GenPoly::getFunctionType( appExpr->func->result );
                        assert( ftype );
                        auto & params = ftype->params;
                        auto iter = params.begin();
                        for ( auto & arg : appExpr->args ) {
                                const ast::Type * formal = nullptr;
                                if ( iter != params.end() ) { // does not copy construct C-style variadic arguments
                                        // DeclarationWithType * param = *iter++;
                                        formal = *iter++;
                                }

                                arg = copyConstructArg( arg, impCpCtorExpr, formal );
                        } // for

                        // each return value from the call needs to be connected with an ObjectDecl at the call site, which is
                        // initialized with the return value and is destructed later
                        // xxx - handle named return values?
                        const ast::Type * result = appExpr->result;
                        if ( ! result->isVoid() ) {
                                static UniqueName retNamer("_tmp_cp_ret");
                                // result = result->clone();
                                auto subResult = env->apply( result ).node;
                                auto ret = new ast::ObjectDecl(loc, retNamer.newName(), subResult, nullptr );
                                auto mutType = mutate(ret->type.get());
                                mutType->set_const( false );
                                ret->type = mutType;
                                returnDecl = ret;
                                stmtsToAddBefore.push_back( new ast::DeclStmt(loc, ret ) );
                                CP_CTOR_PRINT( std::cerr << "makeCtorDtor for a return" << std::endl; )
                        } // for
                        CP_CTOR_PRINT( std::cerr << "after Resolving: " << impCpCtorExpr << std::endl; )
                        // ------------------------------------------------------

                        CP_CTOR_PRINT( std::cerr << "Coming out the back..." << impCpCtorExpr << std::endl; )

                        // detach fields from wrapper node so that it can be deleted without deleting too much

                        // xxx - actual env might be somewhere else, need to keep invariant

                        // deletion of wrapper should be handled by pass template now
                        
                        // impCpCtorExpr->callExpr = nullptr;
                        assert (appExpr->env == nullptr);
                        appExpr->env = impCpCtorExpr->env;
                        // std::swap( impCpCtorExpr->env, appExpr->env );
                        // assert( impCpCtorExpr->env == nullptr );
                        // delete impCpCtorExpr;

                        if ( returnDecl ) {
                                ast::Expr * assign = createBitwiseAssignment( new ast::VariableExpr(loc, returnDecl ), appExpr );
                                if ( ! dynamic_cast< const ast::ReferenceType * >( result ) ) {
                                        // destructing reference returns is bad because it can cause multiple destructor calls to the same object - the returned object is not a temporary
                                        assign = destructRet( returnDecl, assign );
                                        assert(assign);
                                } else {
                                        assign = new ast::CommaExpr(loc, assign, new ast::VariableExpr(loc, returnDecl ) );
                                }
                                // move env from appExpr to retExpr
                                // std::swap( assign->env, appExpr->env );
                                assign->env = appExpr->env;
                                // actual env is handled by common routine that replaces WithTypeSubstitution
                                return postvisit((const ast::Expr *)assign);
                        } else {
                                return postvisit((const ast::Expr *)appExpr);
                        } // if
                }

                const ast::StmtExpr * ResolveCopyCtors::previsit( const ast::StmtExpr * _stmtExpr ) {
                        // function call temporaries should be placed at statement-level, rather than nested inside of a new statement expression,
                        // since temporaries can be shared across sub-expressions, e.g.
                        //   [A, A] f();       // decl
                        //   g([A] x, [A] y);  // decl
                        //   g(f());           // call
                        // f is executed once, so the return temporary is shared across the tuple constructors for x and y.
                        // Explicitly mutating children instead of mutating the inner compound statement forces the temporaries to be added
                        // to the outer context, rather than inside of the statement expression.

                        // call the common routine that replaces WithTypeSubstitution
                        previsit((const ast::Expr *) _stmtExpr);

                        visit_children = false;
                        const CodeLocation loc = _stmtExpr->location;

                        assert( env );

                        symtab.enterScope();
                        // visit all statements
                        auto stmtExpr = mutate(_stmtExpr);
                        auto mutStmts = mutate(stmtExpr->stmts.get());

                        auto & stmts = mutStmts->kids;
                        for ( auto & stmt : stmts ) {
                                stmt = stmt->accept( *visitor );
                        } // for
                        stmtExpr->stmts = mutStmts;
                        symtab.leaveScope();

                        assert( stmtExpr->result );
                        // const ast::Type * result = stmtExpr->result;
                        if ( ! stmtExpr->result->isVoid() ) {
                                static UniqueName retNamer("_tmp_stmtexpr_ret");

                                // result = result->clone();
                                auto result = env->apply( stmtExpr->result.get() ).node;
                                if ( ! InitTweak::isConstructable( result ) ) {
                                        // delete result;
                                        return stmtExpr;
                                }
                                auto mutResult = result.get_and_mutate();
                                mutResult->set_const(false);

                                // create variable that will hold the result of the stmt expr
                                auto ret = new ast::ObjectDecl(loc, retNamer.newName(), mutResult, nullptr );
                                stmtsToAddBefore.push_back( new ast::DeclStmt(loc, ret ) );

                                assertf(
                                        stmtExpr->resultExpr,
                                        "Statement-Expression should have a resulting expression at %s:%d",
                                        stmtExpr->location.filename.c_str(),
                                        stmtExpr->location.first_line
                                );

                                const ast::ExprStmt * last = stmtExpr->resultExpr;
                                // xxx - if this is non-unique, need to copy while making resultExpr ref
                                assertf(last->unique(), "attempt to modify weakly shared statement");
                                auto mutLast = mutate(last);
                                // above assertion means in-place mutation is OK
                                try {
                                        mutLast->expr = makeCtorDtor( "?{}", ret, mutLast->expr );
                                } catch(...) {
                                        std::cerr << "*CFA internal error: ";
                                        std::cerr << "can't resolve implicit constructor";
                                        std::cerr << " at " << stmtExpr->location.filename;
                                        std::cerr << ":" << stmtExpr->location.first_line << std::endl;

                                        abort();
                                }

                                // add destructors after current statement
                                stmtsToAddAfter.push_back( new ast::ExprStmt(loc, makeCtorDtor( "^?{}", ret ) ) );

                                // must have a non-empty body, otherwise it wouldn't have a result
                                assert( ! stmts.empty() );

                                // if there is a return decl, add a use as the last statement; will not have return decl on non-constructable returns
                                stmts.push_back( new ast::ExprStmt(loc, new ast::VariableExpr(loc, ret ) ) );
                        } // if

                        assert( stmtExpr->returnDecls.empty() );
                        assert( stmtExpr->dtors.empty() );

                        return stmtExpr;
                }

                // to prevent warnings ('_unq0' may be used uninitialized in this function),
                // insert an appropriate zero initializer for UniqueExpr temporaries.
                ast::Init * makeInit( const ast::Type * t ) {
                        if ( auto inst = dynamic_cast< const ast::StructInstType * >( t ) ) {
                                // initizer for empty struct must be empty
                                if ( inst->base->members.empty() ) return new ast::ListInit({}, {});
                        } else if ( auto inst = dynamic_cast< const ast::UnionInstType * >( t ) ) {
                                // initizer for empty union must be empty
                                if ( inst->base->members.empty() ) return new ast::ListInit({}, {});
                        }

                        return new ast::ListInit( {}, { new ast::SingleInit( {}, ast::ConstantExpr::from_int({}, 0) ) } );
                }

                const ast::UniqueExpr * ResolveCopyCtors::previsit( const ast::UniqueExpr * unqExpr ) {
                        visit_children = false;
                        // xxx - hack to prevent double-handling of unique exprs, otherwise too many temporary variables and destructors are generated
                        static std::unordered_map< int, const ast::UniqueExpr * > unqMap;
                        auto mutExpr = mutate(unqExpr);
                        if ( ! unqMap.count( unqExpr->id ) ) {
                                // resolve expr and find its

                                auto impCpCtorExpr = mutExpr->expr.as<ast::ImplicitCopyCtorExpr>();
                                // PassVisitor<ResolveCopyCtors> fixer;
                                
                                mutExpr->expr = mutExpr->expr->accept( *visitor );
                                // it should never be necessary to wrap a void-returning expression in a UniqueExpr - if this assumption changes, this needs to be rethought
                                assert( unqExpr->result );
                                if ( impCpCtorExpr ) {
                                        auto comma = unqExpr->expr.strict_as<ast::CommaExpr>();
                                        auto var = comma->arg2.strict_as<ast::VariableExpr>();
                                        // note the variable used as the result from the call
                                        mutExpr->var = var;
                                } else {
                                        // expr isn't a call expr, so create a new temporary variable to use to hold the value of the unique expression
                                        mutExpr->object = new ast::ObjectDecl( mutExpr->location, toString("_unq", mutExpr->id), mutExpr->result, makeInit( mutExpr->result ) );
                                        mutExpr->var = new ast::VariableExpr( mutExpr->location, mutExpr->object );
                                }

                                // stmtsToAddBefore.splice( stmtsToAddBefore.end(), fixer.pass.stmtsToAddBefore );
                                // stmtsToAddAfter.splice( stmtsToAddAfter.end(), fixer.pass.stmtsToAddAfter );
                                unqMap[mutExpr->id] = mutExpr;
                        } else {
                                // take data from other UniqueExpr to ensure consistency
                                // delete unqExpr->get_expr();
                                mutExpr->expr = unqMap[mutExpr->id]->expr;
                                // delete unqExpr->result;
                                mutExpr->result = mutExpr->expr->result;
                        }
                        return mutExpr;
                }

                const ast::DeclWithType * FixInit::postvisit( const ast::ObjectDecl *_objDecl ) {
                        const CodeLocation loc = _objDecl->location;

                        // since this removes the init field from objDecl, it must occur after children are mutated (i.e. postvisit)
                        if ( ast::ptr<ast::ConstructorInit> ctorInit = _objDecl->init.as<ast::ConstructorInit>() ) {
                                auto objDecl = mutate(_objDecl);

                                // could this be non-unique?
                                if (objDecl != _objDecl) {
                                        std::cerr << "FixInit: non-unique object decl " << objDecl->location << objDecl->name << std::endl;
                                }
                                // a decision should have been made by the resolver, so ctor and init are not both non-NULL
                                assert( ! ctorInit->ctor || ! ctorInit->init );
                                if ( const ast::Stmt * ctor = ctorInit->ctor ) {
                                        if ( objDecl->storage.is_static ) {
                                                // originally wanted to take advantage of gcc nested functions, but
                                                // we get memory errors with this approach. To remedy this, the static
                                                // variable is hoisted when the destructor needs to be called.
                                                //
                                                // generate:
                                                // static T __objName_static_varN;
                                                // void __objName_dtor_atexitN() {
                                                //   __dtor__...;
                                                // }
                                                // int f(...) {
                                                //   ...
                                                //   static bool __objName_uninitialized = true;
                                                //   if (__objName_uninitialized) {
                                                //     __ctor(__objName);
                                                //     __objName_uninitialized = false;
                                                //     atexit(__objName_dtor_atexitN);
                                                //   }
                                                //   ...
                                                // }

                                                static UniqueName dtorCallerNamer( "_dtor_atexit" );

                                                // static bool __objName_uninitialized = true
                                                auto boolType = new ast::BasicType( ast::BasicType::Kind::Bool );
                                                auto boolInitExpr = new ast::SingleInit(loc, ast::ConstantExpr::from_int(loc, 1 ) );
                                                auto isUninitializedVar = new ast::ObjectDecl(loc, objDecl->mangleName + "_uninitialized", boolType, boolInitExpr, ast::Storage::Static, ast::Linkage::Cforall);
                                                isUninitializedVar->fixUniqueId();

                                                // __objName_uninitialized = false;
                                                auto setTrue = new ast::UntypedExpr(loc, new ast::NameExpr(loc, "?=?" ) );
                                                setTrue->args.push_back( new ast::VariableExpr(loc, isUninitializedVar ) );
                                                setTrue->args.push_back( ast::ConstantExpr::from_int(loc, 0 ) );

                                                // generate body of if
                                                auto initStmts = new ast::CompoundStmt(loc);
                                                auto & body = initStmts->kids;
                                                body.push_back( ctor );
                                                body.push_back( new ast::ExprStmt(loc, setTrue ) );

                                                // put it all together
                                                auto ifStmt = new ast::IfStmt(loc, new ast::VariableExpr(loc, isUninitializedVar ), initStmts, 0 );
                                                stmtsToAddAfter.push_back( new ast::DeclStmt(loc, isUninitializedVar ) );
                                                stmtsToAddAfter.push_back( ifStmt );

                                                const ast::Stmt * dtor = ctorInit->dtor;

                                                // these should be automatically managed once reassigned
                                                // objDecl->set_init( nullptr );
                                                // ctorInit->set_ctor( nullptr );
                                                // ctorInit->set_dtor( nullptr );
                                                if ( dtor ) {
                                                        // if the object has a non-trivial destructor, have to
                                                        // hoist it and the object into the global space and
                                                        // call the destructor function with atexit.

                                                        // Statement * dtorStmt = dtor->clone();

                                                        // void __objName_dtor_atexitN(...) {...}
                                                        ast::FunctionDecl * dtorCaller = new ast::FunctionDecl(loc, objDecl->mangleName + dtorCallerNamer.newName(), {}, {}, {}, new ast::CompoundStmt(loc, {dtor}), ast::Storage::Static, ast::Linkage::C );
                                                        dtorCaller->fixUniqueId();
                                                        // dtorCaller->stmts->push_back( dtor );

                                                        // atexit(dtor_atexit);
                                                        auto callAtexit = new ast::UntypedExpr(loc, new ast::NameExpr(loc, "atexit" ) );
                                                        callAtexit->args.push_back( new ast::VariableExpr(loc, dtorCaller ) );

                                                        body.push_back( new ast::ExprStmt(loc, callAtexit ) );

                                                        // hoist variable and dtor caller decls to list of decls that will be added into global scope
                                                        staticDtorDecls.push_back( objDecl );
                                                        staticDtorDecls.push_back( dtorCaller );

                                                        // need to rename object uniquely since it now appears
                                                        // at global scope and there could be multiple function-scoped
                                                        // static variables with the same name in different functions.
                                                        // Note: it isn't sufficient to modify only the mangleName, because
                                                        // then subsequent Indexer passes can choke on seeing the object's name
                                                        // if another object has the same name and type. An unfortunate side-effect
                                                        // of renaming the object is that subsequent NameExprs may fail to resolve,
                                                        // but there shouldn't be any remaining past this point.
                                                        static UniqueName staticNamer( "_static_var" );
                                                        objDecl->name = objDecl->name + staticNamer.newName();
                                                        objDecl->mangleName = Mangle::mangle( objDecl );

                                                        // xxx - temporary hack: need to return a declaration, but want to hoist the current object out of this scope
                                                        // create a new object which is never used
                                                        static UniqueName dummyNamer( "_dummy" );
                                                        auto dummy = new ast::ObjectDecl(loc, dummyNamer.newName(), new ast::PointerType(new ast::VoidType()), nullptr, ast::Storage::Static, ast::Linkage::Cforall, 0, { new ast::Attribute("unused") } );
                                                        // delete ctorInit;
                                                        return dummy;
                                                } else {
                                                        objDecl->init = nullptr;
                                                        return objDecl;
                                                }
                                        } else {
                                                auto implicit = strict_dynamic_cast< const ast::ImplicitCtorDtorStmt * > ( ctor );
                                                auto ctorStmt = implicit->callStmt.as<ast::ExprStmt>();
                                                const ast::ApplicationExpr * ctorCall = nullptr;
                                                if ( ctorStmt && (ctorCall = isIntrinsicCallExpr( ctorStmt->expr )) && ctorCall->args.size() == 2 ) {
                                                        // clean up intrinsic copy constructor calls by making them into SingleInits
                                                        const ast::Expr * ctorArg = ctorCall->args.back();
                                                        // ctorCall should be gone afterwards
                                                        auto mutArg = mutate(ctorArg);
                                                        mutArg->env = ctorCall->env;
                                                        // std::swap( ctorArg->env, ctorCall->env );
                                                        objDecl->init = new ast::SingleInit(loc, mutArg );

                                                        // ctorCall->args.pop_back();
                                                } else {
                                                        stmtsToAddAfter.push_back( ctor );
                                                        objDecl->init = nullptr;
                                                        // ctorInit->ctor = nullptr;
                                                }

                                                const ast::Stmt * dtor = ctorInit->dtor;
                                                if ( dtor ) {
                                                        auto implicit = strict_dynamic_cast< const ast::ImplicitCtorDtorStmt * >( dtor );
                                                        const ast::Stmt * dtorStmt = implicit->callStmt;

                                                        // don't need to call intrinsic dtor, because it does nothing, but
                                                        // non-intrinsic dtors must be called
                                                        if ( ! isIntrinsicSingleArgCallStmt( dtorStmt ) ) {
                                                                // set dtor location to the object's location for error messages
                                                                auto dtorFunc = getDtorFunc( objDecl, dtorStmt, stmtsToAddBefore );
                                                                objDecl->attributes.push_back( new ast::Attribute( "cleanup", { new ast::VariableExpr(loc, dtorFunc ) } ) );
                                                                // ctorInit->dtor = nullptr;
                                                        } // if
                                                }
                                        } // if
                                } else if ( const ast::Init * init = ctorInit->init ) {
                                        objDecl->init = init;
                                        // ctorInit->init = nullptr;
                                } else {
                                        // no constructor and no initializer, which is okay
                                        objDecl->init = nullptr;
                                } // if
                                // delete ctorInit;
                                return objDecl;
                        } // if
                        return _objDecl;
                }

                void ObjDeclCollector::previsit( const ast::CompoundStmt * ) {
                        GuardValue( curVars );
                }

                void ObjDeclCollector::previsit( const ast::DeclStmt * stmt ) {
                        // keep track of all variables currently in scope
                        if ( auto objDecl = stmt->decl.as<ast::ObjectDecl>() ) {
                                curVars.push_back( objDecl );
                        } // if
                }

                void LabelFinder::previsit( const ast::Stmt * stmt ) {
                        // for each label, remember the variables in scope at that label.
                        for ( auto l : stmt->labels ) {
                                vars[l] = curVars;
                        } // for
                }

                void LabelFinder::previsit( const ast::CompoundStmt * stmt ) {
                        previsit( (const ast::Stmt *) stmt );
                        Parent::previsit( stmt );
                }

                void LabelFinder::previsit( const ast::DeclStmt * stmt ) {
                        previsit( (const ast::Stmt *)stmt );
                        Parent::previsit( stmt );
                }


                void InsertDtors::previsit( const ast::FunctionDecl * funcDecl ) {
                        // each function needs to have its own set of labels
                        GuardValue( labelVars );
                        labelVars.clear();
                        // LabelFinder does not recurse into FunctionDecl, so need to visit
                        // its children manually.
                        if (funcDecl->type) funcDecl->type->accept(finder);
                        // maybeAccept( funcDecl->type, finder );
                        if (funcDecl->stmts) funcDecl->stmts->accept(finder) ;

                        // all labels for this function have been collected, insert destructors as appropriate via implicit recursion.
                }

                // Handle break/continue/goto in the same manner as C++.  Basic idea: any objects that are in scope at the
                // BranchStmt but not at the labelled (target) statement must be destructed.  If there are any objects in scope
                // at the target location but not at the BranchStmt then those objects would be uninitialized so notify the user
                // of the error.  See C++ Reference 6.6 Jump Statements for details.
                void InsertDtors::handleGoto( const ast::BranchStmt * stmt ) {
                        // can't do anything for computed goto
                        if ( stmt->computedTarget ) return;

                        assertf( stmt->target.name != "", "BranchStmt missing a label: %s", toString( stmt ).c_str() );
                        // S_L = lvars = set of objects in scope at label definition
                        // S_G = curVars = set of objects in scope at goto statement
                        ObjectSet & lvars = labelVars[ stmt->target ];

                        DTOR_PRINT(
                                std::cerr << "at goto label: " << stmt->target.name << std::endl;
                                std::cerr << "S_G = " << printSet( curVars ) << std::endl;
                                std::cerr << "S_L = " << printSet( lvars ) << std::endl;
                        )


                        // std::set_difference requires that the inputs be sorted.
                        lvars.sort();
                        curVars.sort();

                        ObjectSet diff;
                        // S_L-S_G results in set of objects whose construction is skipped - it's an error if this set is non-empty
                        std::set_difference( lvars.begin(), lvars.end(), curVars.begin(), curVars.end(), std::inserter( diff, diff.begin() ) );
                        DTOR_PRINT(
                                std::cerr << "S_L-S_G = " << printSet( diff ) << std::endl;
                        )
                        if ( ! diff.empty() ) {
                                SemanticError( stmt, std::string("jump to label '") + stmt->target.name + "' crosses initialization of " + (*diff.begin())->name + " " );
                        } // if
                }

                void InsertDtors::previsit( const ast::BranchStmt * stmt ) {
                        switch( stmt->kind ) {
                          case ast::BranchStmt::Continue:
                          case ast::BranchStmt::Break:
                                // could optimize the break/continue case, because the S_L-S_G check is unnecessary (this set should
                                // always be empty), but it serves as a small sanity check.
                          case ast::BranchStmt::Goto:
                                handleGoto( stmt );
                                break;
                          default:
                                assert( false );
                        } // switch
                }

                bool checkWarnings( const ast::FunctionDecl * funcDecl ) {
                        // only check for warnings if the current function is a user-defined
                        // constructor or destructor
                        if ( ! funcDecl ) return false;
                        if ( ! funcDecl->stmts ) return false;
                        return CodeGen::isCtorDtor( funcDecl->name ) && ! funcDecl->linkage.is_overrideable;
                }

                void GenStructMemberCalls::previsit( const ast::FunctionDecl * funcDecl ) {
                        GuardValue( function );
                        GuardValue( unhandled );
                        GuardValue( usedUninit );
                        GuardValue( thisParam );
                        GuardValue( isCtor );
                        GuardValue( structDecl );
                        errors = SemanticErrorException();  // clear previous errors

                        // need to start with fresh sets
                        unhandled.clear();
                        usedUninit.clear();

                        function = mutate(funcDecl);
                        // could this be non-unique?
                        if (function != funcDecl) {
                                std::cerr << "GenStructMemberCalls: non-unique FunctionDecl " << funcDecl->location << funcDecl->name << std::endl;
                        }

                        isCtor = CodeGen::isConstructor( function->name );
                        if ( checkWarnings( function ) ) {
                                // const ast::FunctionType * type = function->type;
                                // assert( ! type->params.empty() );
                                thisParam = function->params.front().strict_as<ast::ObjectDecl>();
                                auto thisType = getPointerBase( thisParam->get_type() );
                                auto structType = dynamic_cast< const ast::StructInstType * >( thisType );
                                if ( structType ) {
                                        structDecl = structType->base;
                                        for ( auto & member : structDecl->members ) {
                                                if ( auto field = member.as<ast::ObjectDecl>() ) {
                                                        // record all of the struct type's members that need to be constructed or
                                                        // destructed by the end of the function
                                                        unhandled.insert( field );
                                                }
                                        }
                                }
                        }
                }

                const ast::DeclWithType * GenStructMemberCalls::postvisit( const ast::FunctionDecl * funcDecl ) {
                        // remove the unhandled objects from usedUninit, because a call is inserted
                        // to handle them - only objects that are later constructed are used uninitialized.
                        std::map< const ast::DeclWithType *, CodeLocation > diff;
                        // need the comparator since usedUninit and unhandled have different types
                        struct comp_t {
                                typedef decltype(usedUninit)::value_type usedUninit_t;
                                typedef decltype(unhandled)::value_type unhandled_t;
                                bool operator()(usedUninit_t x, unhandled_t y) { return x.first < y; }
                                bool operator()(unhandled_t x, usedUninit_t y) { return x < y.first; }
                        } comp;
                        std::set_difference( usedUninit.begin(), usedUninit.end(), unhandled.begin(), unhandled.end(), std::inserter( diff, diff.begin() ), comp );
                        for ( auto p : diff ) {
                                auto member = p.first;
                                auto loc = p.second;
                                // xxx - make error message better by also tracking the location that the object is constructed at?
                                emit( loc, "in ", function->name, ", field ", member->name, " used before being constructed" );
                        }

                        const CodeLocation loc = funcDecl->location;

                        if ( ! unhandled.empty() ) {
                                auto mutStmts = function->stmts.get_and_mutate();
                                // need to explicitly re-add function parameters to the indexer in order to resolve copy constructors
                                auto guard = makeFuncGuard( [this]() { symtab.enterScope(); }, [this]() { symtab.leaveScope(); } );
                                symtab.addFunction( function );

                                // need to iterate through members in reverse in order for
                                // ctor/dtor statements to come out in the right order
                                for ( auto & member : reverseIterate( structDecl->members ) ) {
                                        auto field = member.as<ast::ObjectDecl>();
                                        // skip non-DWT members
                                        if ( ! field ) continue;
                                        // skip non-constructable members
                                        if ( ! tryConstruct( field ) ) continue;
                                        // skip handled members
                                        if ( ! unhandled.count( field ) ) continue;

                                        // insert and resolve default/copy constructor call for each field that's unhandled
                                        // std::list< const ast::Stmt * > stmt;
                                        ast::Expr * arg2 = nullptr;
                                        if ( function->name == "?{}" && isCopyFunction( function ) ) {
                                                // if copy ctor, need to pass second-param-of-this-function.field
                                                // std::list< DeclarationWithType * > & params = function->get_functionType()->get_parameters();
                                                assert( function->params.size() == 2 );
                                                arg2 = new ast::MemberExpr(funcDecl->location, field, new ast::VariableExpr(funcDecl->location, function->params.back() ) );
                                        }
                                        InitExpander_new srcParam( arg2 );
                                        // cast away reference type and construct field.
                                        ast::Expr * thisExpr = new ast::CastExpr(funcDecl->location, new ast::VariableExpr(funcDecl->location, thisParam ), thisParam->get_type()->stripReferences());
                                        ast::Expr * memberDest = new ast::MemberExpr(funcDecl->location, field, thisExpr );
                                        ast::ptr<ast::Stmt> callStmt = SymTab::genImplicitCall( srcParam, memberDest, loc, function->name, field, static_cast<SymTab::LoopDirection>(isCtor) );

                                        if ( callStmt ) {
                                                // auto & callStmt = stmt.front();

                                                try {
                                                        callStmt = callStmt->accept( *visitor );
                                                        if ( isCtor ) {
                                                                mutStmts->push_front( callStmt );
                                                        } else { // TODO: don't generate destructor function/object for intrinsic calls
                                                                // destructor statements should be added at the end
                                                                // function->get_statements()->push_back( callStmt );

                                                                // Optimization: do not need to call intrinsic destructors on members
                                                                if ( isIntrinsicSingleArgCallStmt( callStmt ) ) continue;

                                                                // __Destructor _dtor0 = { (void *)&b.a1, (void (*)(void *)_destroy_A };
                                                                std::list< ast::ptr<ast::Stmt> > stmtsToAdd;

                                                                static UniqueName memberDtorNamer = { "__memberDtor" };
                                                                assertf( Validate::dtorStruct, "builtin __Destructor not found." );
                                                                assertf( Validate::dtorStructDestroy, "builtin __destroy_Destructor not found." );

                                                                ast::Expr * thisExpr = new ast::CastExpr( new ast::AddressExpr( new ast::VariableExpr(loc, thisParam ) ), new ast::PointerType( new ast::VoidType(), ast::CV::Qualifiers() ) );
                                                                ast::Expr * dtorExpr = new ast::VariableExpr(loc, getDtorFunc( thisParam, callStmt, stmtsToAdd ) );

                                                                // cast destructor pointer to void (*)(void *), to silence GCC incompatible pointer warnings
                                                                auto dtorFtype = new ast::FunctionType();
                                                                dtorFtype->params.emplace_back( new ast::PointerType( new ast::VoidType() ) );
                                                                auto dtorType = new ast::PointerType( dtorFtype );

                                                                auto destructor = new ast::ObjectDecl(loc, memberDtorNamer.newName(), new ast::StructInstType( ast::dtorStruct ), new ast::ListInit(loc, { new ast::SingleInit(loc, thisExpr ), new ast::SingleInit(loc, new ast::CastExpr( dtorExpr, dtorType ) ) } ) );
                                                                destructor->attributes.push_back( new ast::Attribute( "cleanup", { new ast::VariableExpr({}, ast::dtorStructDestroy ) } ) );
                                                                mutStmts->push_front( new ast::DeclStmt(loc, destructor ) );
                                                                mutStmts->kids.splice( mutStmts->kids.begin(), stmtsToAdd );
                                                        }
                                                } catch ( SemanticErrorException & error ) {
                                                        emit( funcDecl->location, "in ", function->name , ", field ", field->name, " not explicitly ", isCtor ? "constructed" : "destructed",  " and no ", isCtor ? "default constructor" : "destructor", " found" );
                                                }
                                        }
                                }
                                function->stmts = mutStmts;
                        }
                        if (! errors.isEmpty()) {
                                throw errors;
                        }
                        // return funcDecl;
                        return function;
                }

                /// true if expr is effectively just the 'this' parameter
                bool isThisExpression( const ast::Expr * expr, const ast::DeclWithType * thisParam ) {
                        // TODO: there are more complicated ways to pass 'this' to a constructor, e.g. &*, *&, etc.
                        if ( auto varExpr = dynamic_cast< const ast::VariableExpr * >( expr ) ) {
                                return varExpr->var == thisParam;
                        } else if ( auto castExpr = dynamic_cast< const ast::CastExpr * > ( expr ) ) {
                                return isThisExpression( castExpr->arg, thisParam );
                        }
                        return false;
                }

                /// returns a MemberExpr if expr is effectively just member access on the 'this' parameter, else nullptr
                const ast::MemberExpr * isThisMemberExpr( const ast::Expr * expr, const ast::DeclWithType * thisParam ) {
                        if ( auto memberExpr = dynamic_cast< const ast::MemberExpr * >( expr ) ) {
                                if ( isThisExpression( memberExpr->aggregate, thisParam ) ) {
                                        return memberExpr;
                                }
                        } else if ( auto castExpr = dynamic_cast< const ast::CastExpr * >( expr ) ) {
                                return isThisMemberExpr( castExpr->arg, thisParam );
                        }
                        return nullptr;
                }

                void GenStructMemberCalls::previsit( const ast::ApplicationExpr * appExpr ) {
                        if ( ! checkWarnings( function ) ) {
                                visit_children = false;
                                return;
                        }

                        std::string fname = getFunctionName( appExpr );
                        if ( fname == function->name ) {
                                // call to same kind of function
                                const ast::Expr * firstParam = appExpr->args.front();

                                if ( isThisExpression( firstParam, thisParam ) ) {
                                        // if calling another constructor on thisParam, assume that function handles
                                        // all members - if it doesn't a warning will appear in that function.
                                        unhandled.clear();
                                } else if ( auto memberExpr = isThisMemberExpr( firstParam, thisParam ) ) {
                                        // if first parameter is a member expression on the this parameter,
                                        // then remove the member from unhandled set.
                                        if ( isThisExpression( memberExpr->aggregate, thisParam ) ) {
                                                unhandled.erase( memberExpr->member );
                                        }
                                }
                        }
                }

                void GenStructMemberCalls::previsit( const ast::MemberExpr * memberExpr ) {
                        if ( ! checkWarnings( function ) || ! isCtor ) {
                                visit_children = false;
                                return;
                        }

                        if ( isThisExpression( memberExpr->aggregate, thisParam ) ) {
                                if ( unhandled.count( memberExpr->member ) ) {
                                        // emit a warning because a member was used before it was constructed
                                        usedUninit.insert( { memberExpr->member, memberExpr->location } );
                                }
                        }
                }

                template< typename Visitor, typename... Params >
                void error( Visitor & v, CodeLocation loc, const Params &... params ) {
                        SemanticErrorException err( loc, toString( params... ) );
                        v.errors.append( err );
                }

                template< typename... Params >
                void GenStructMemberCalls::emit( CodeLocation loc, const Params &... params ) {
                        // toggle warnings vs. errors here.
                        // warn( params... );
                        error( *this, loc, params... );
                }

                const ast::Expr * GenStructMemberCalls::postvisit( const ast::UntypedExpr * untypedExpr ) {
                        // Expression * newExpr = untypedExpr;
                        // xxx - functions returning ast::ptr seems wrong...
                        auto res = ResolvExpr::findVoidExpression( untypedExpr, symtab );
                        return res.release();
                        // return newExpr;
                }

                void InsertImplicitCalls::previsit(const ast::UniqueExpr * unqExpr) {
                        if (visitedIds.count(unqExpr->id)) visit_children = false;
                        else visitedIds.insert(unqExpr->id);
                }

                const ast::Expr * FixCtorExprs::postvisit( const ast::ConstructorExpr * ctorExpr ) {
                        const CodeLocation loc = ctorExpr->location;
                        static UniqueName tempNamer( "_tmp_ctor_expr" );
                        // xxx - is the size check necessary?
                        assert( ctorExpr->result && ctorExpr->result->size() == 1 );

                        // xxx - this can be TupleAssignExpr now. Need to properly handle this case.
                        // take possession of expr and env
                        ast::ptr<ast::ApplicationExpr> callExpr = ctorExpr->callExpr.strict_as<ast::ApplicationExpr>();
                        ast::ptr<ast::TypeSubstitution> env = ctorExpr->env;
                        // ctorExpr->set_callExpr( nullptr );
                        // ctorExpr->set_env( nullptr );

                        // xxx - ideally we would reuse the temporary generated from the copy constructor passes from within firstArg if it exists and not generate a temporary if it's unnecessary.
                        auto tmp = new ast::ObjectDecl(loc, tempNamer.newName(), callExpr->args.front()->result );
                        declsToAddBefore.push_back( tmp );
                        // delete ctorExpr;

                        // build assignment and replace constructor's first argument with new temporary
                        auto mutCallExpr = callExpr.get_and_mutate();
                        const ast::Expr * firstArg = callExpr->args.front();
                        ast::Expr * assign = new ast::UntypedExpr(loc, new ast::NameExpr(loc, "?=?" ), { new ast::AddressExpr(loc, new ast::VariableExpr(loc, tmp ) ), new ast::AddressExpr( firstArg ) } );
                        firstArg = new ast::VariableExpr(loc, tmp );
                        mutCallExpr->args.front() = firstArg;

                        // resolve assignment and dispose of new env
                        auto resolved = ResolvExpr::findVoidExpression( assign, symtab );
                        auto mut = resolved.get_and_mutate();
                        assertf(resolved.get() == mut, "newly resolved expression must be unique");
                        mut->env = nullptr;

                        // for constructor expr:
                        //   T x;
                        //   x{};
                        // results in:
                        //   T x;
                        //   T & tmp;
                        //   &tmp = &x, ?{}(tmp), tmp
                        ast::CommaExpr * commaExpr = new ast::CommaExpr(loc, resolved, new ast::CommaExpr(loc, mutCallExpr, new ast::VariableExpr(loc, tmp ) ) );
                        commaExpr->env = env;
                        return commaExpr;
                }
        } // namespace
} // namespace InitTweak

// Local Variables: //
// tab-width: 4 //
// mode: c++ //
// compile-command: "make install" //
// End: //